Skip to content
MergeGuard

    Start with

    Playbook

    Studies of reward cards found people buy more as a reward gets closer. Those studies were about coffee and car-wash style cards, not online spend thresholds. Treat a Close to VIP nudge as a test with a holdout group, and measure orders over a window you set, instead of expecting a lift.

    By MergeGuard team

    3 min read

    Key insight

    The research supports running a nudge test. It doesn’t support expecting a lift.

    4 words used here
    NudgeA message that encourages a customer to place one more order.
    Holdout groupThe part of the list that gets no nudge, so you can see what would have happened anyway.
    Goal-gradientPeople act faster as a reward gets closer.
    Endowed progressA task that already looks partly done feels easier to finish.

    What the studies found

    Two well-known papers look at how people respond as a reward gets nearer.

    • Goal-gradient. Kivetz, Urminsky and Zheng studied reward programs. In a café with a free-coffee card, members bought coffee more often as they got closer to a free coffee. Customers given a 12-stamp card with two bonus stamps already filled in finished the 10 required purchases faster than customers given a regular 10-stamp card (abstract of the 2006 working paper).
    • Endowed progress. Nunes and Drèze, in the Journal of Consumer Research, found that reframing an eight-step task as a ten-step task with two steps already complete “increases the likelihood of task completion and decreases completion time” (abstract).

    What they don’t show

    The studies tested stamp cards for repeat purchases, with a free coffee as the goal, and did not count the cost of the reward. Your store would be moving a dollar spend threshold, and an offer can cost margin.

    A customer a few dollars short of VIP might respond differently from a customer one coffee short of a free one.

    Blog posts quote card redemption rates, but those figures came through secondary summaries and are unconfirmed against the original papers.

    Build the list

    The people to nudge are those who are close to the threshold and haven’t reached it. Count spend per person. A customer whose orders sit on two profiles can look far from the threshold on each, when together they are close or already over it (why split profiles hide your VIPs). You’d nudge someone who is already a VIP, or miss someone who is nearly there.

    MergeGuard’s VIP audience lists customers near your threshold, counted across all their profiles (VIP lists). Every plan shows the VIP counts, and the lists come with higher plans (see pricing). Help shows the VIP lists in MergeGuard.

    Without a tool, the list is everyone under the threshold whose total is within a margin you choose.

    Run a test with a holdout

    Without a holdout group you cannot tell a nudge’s effect from ordinary buying. The steps at the end of this page split the list at random, so the two halves are alike.

    Half the list: Nudge group, Gets a message from your own tool.. The other half: Holdout group, Gets nothing, so it sets the baseline., Not contacted.Half the listNudge groupGets a message from your own tool.The other halfHoldout groupGets nothing, so it sets the baseline.Not contacted
    The holdout group shows what would have happened anyway.

    Success is more orders from the nudge group than from the holdout group over the window you set. Failure is no difference, or a difference that the cost of the offer cancels out. Both are useful answers.

    Read the result

    On a small list, a few orders can come from chance. In a small group, one extra order is a large share of the result. Treat a small gap as no result. Repeat the test on the next group to cross the threshold if the first one is unclear.

    Where to send

    Send the nudge from your own email tool, and only to customers who have agreed to hear from you. Check marketing consent there before you send.

    Step by step

    1. List the people close to the threshold

      List the people near your threshold who have not reached it. Count spend across each person’s profiles, not per profile.

    2. Split the list at random

      Put half in a nudge group and half in a holdout group that gets no message. Splitting at random keeps the groups alike.

    3. Set the window and the measure

      Decide the period, such as the next month, and the measure, such as orders placed or spend. Write both down before you start.

    4. Send the nudge from your own tool

      Send the nudge group a message through your own email tool. The holdout group gets nothing.

    5. Read the result

      Compare orders per person in the two groups over the window. Count a difference as real only if it is bigger than the swings you would expect in a list this size.

    Question about this chapter? Email support@mergeguard.store.

    Keep reading (6 links: 2 Guides, 1 Help, 1 Feature, 2 Sources)

    0 of 4 readSaved in this browser only.